Objectives, endpoints and criteria have no link to document sections

https://kerfors.github.io/usdm-overlay/id/finding/design-elements-not-linked-to-document

No property connects Objective, Endpoint, EligibilityCriterion or EligibilityCriterionItem to the document structure (StudyDefinitionDocument, StudyDefinitionDocumentVersion, NarrativeContent, NarrativeContentItem, DocumentContentReference), in either direction.

standing

For discussion: The model may leave the link between design elements and document sections out of scope on purpose.

evidence

Model-stated

holds

true

observation

ASK returned false, expected false.

about

EligibilityCriterion, EligibilityCriterionItem, Endpoint, NarrativeContent, Objective

sources

https://github.com/kerfors/usdm-rdf/blob/v0.7.1/usdm_v4.ttl

Test

SPARQL ASK over usdm_v4.ttl, expected false.

PREFIX rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#>
PREFIX owl: <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#>
PREFIX rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#>
PREFIX usdm: <https://w3id.org/cdisc/usdm/v4/>
ASK {
    {
        VALUES ?d { usdm:Objective usdm:Endpoint usdm:SyntaxTemplate usdm:EligibilityCriterion usdm:EligibilityCriterionItem }
        VALUES ?r { usdm:StudyDefinitionDocument usdm:StudyDefinitionDocumentVersion usdm:NarrativeContent
                    usdm:NarrativeContentItem usdm:DocumentContentReference }
        ?p rdfs:domain ?d ; rdfs:range/(owl:unionOf/rdf:rest*/rdf:first)? ?r .
    } UNION {
        VALUES ?d { usdm:StudyDefinitionDocument usdm:StudyDefinitionDocumentVersion usdm:NarrativeContent
                    usdm:NarrativeContentItem usdm:DocumentContentReference }
        VALUES ?r { usdm:Objective usdm:Endpoint usdm:SyntaxTemplate usdm:EligibilityCriterion usdm:EligibilityCriterionItem }
        ?p rdfs:domain ?d ; rdfs:range/(owl:unionOf/rdf:rest*/rdf:first)? ?r .
    }
}